Nike’s Irony

The Grand Brand That Turned Timid Before Turning Bold

If Nike, the brand that taught the world how to sell culture, can forget what made it great, what chance do the rest of us have?

Two recent takes from Digiday and Modern Retail point to Nike’s “tentative turnaround.” 

Both highlight a shift back to brand thinking. 

Both miss the deeper truth.

This is the irony of Nike’s recent turnaround. 

The company that built modern cultural marketing abandoned its foundation for performance addiction.
It stopped leading culture and started chasing clicks. 

For a moment, the grand brand turned timid.
Now it is trying to look bold again.

Most will see Nike’s pivot as a clever move. It is not. 

It is a warning. Brand equity does not sit still. It builds, or it bleeds.

The performance trap

The pressure to prove ROI is relentless. 

Boards demand instant numbers.
CMOs panic about the quarter. 

So brands feed the machine.
More paid spend.
More discounts.
More quick wins.

The logic is fake. 

The CFO sees a spike and calls it growth.
But spikes are not growth.
They are withdrawals from the brand account.
Every discount erodes desire.
Every click-driven campaign kills distinctiveness.

Nike’s problem was not product. 

They still had athletes and drops.
What they forgot is simple.
Culture is not a spreadsheet.

Nike’s pivot back

Nike has pulled back on promotions. That is more than margin protection. 

It is a signal. 

If your equity collapses when you stop discounting, you never had equity at all.

They are decentralising categories while trying to keep the ethos intact.
That is not a management tweak. 

It is survival.

Most importantly, Nike is crawling back to brand storytelling.
Trying to speak to culture, not just the checkout page.
It is hesitant, not heroic.
But it shows they remember that campaigns cannot replace culture.

And here is the bigger shift. 

Even boardrooms are relearning patience.
When the directors who once demanded quarterly fireworks start pushing for brand thinking, you know the short-termism disease has gone too far.

Build or bleed

Brand equity is not a trophy you win once. 

It is a muscle. You train it, or it atrophies.

When Nike went performance-first, it bled.
Not in headlines, but in meaning.
Every quarter of promo over purpose drained the reservoir.
Every campaign optimised for clicks over culture chipped at the core.

The same law applies to every founder.
If you are not building, you are bleeding.
Nike had decades of deposits. You do not.

The bridge and the engine

Brand is the bridge people cross to enter your world. 

Performance is the engine that moves them once they are inside. 

Without the bridge, the engine spins in place.

Nike never lost the engine. They had global reach and paid power.
What cracked was the bridge.
Without cultural relevance, people stop crossing. 

They scroll past.
They buy on price.
They treat you as replaceable.

Rebuilding brand is not nostalgia. 

It is structural repair. A bridge you neglect will collapse.

The warning

Most companies are not Nike. You do not have 30 years of cultural deposits.
You do not have icons or athletes.
You do not have a swoosh that can withstand bleeding.

So if you copy Nike’s mistake and chase performance at the expense of brand, you will not get a comeback. 

You will vanish. Nike had equity to burn. You do not.

Performance feels safe. But it is not strength. It is dependency.
When the media budget dries up, your growth disappears with it.
What remains? A hollow logo.

The choice

Keep feeding the machine. Keep chasing spikes and calling it strategy.
Or make the harder choice. 

Build equity. 

Anchor yourself in culture.
Refuse to trade tomorrow for today.

Nike became timid when pressure mounted.
But they had the luxury to turn bold again. You do not.

Nike turned timid before it turned bold. 

Your brand will not get the same second chance.

Build cultural relevance now. 

Or disappear.

—

The hard truth:

• Brand equity does not sit still. It builds, or it bleeds.

• Brand is the trust bridge. Performance is just the engine.

• When you mistake spikes for strategy, you bleed out.

Nike has the luxury to rediscover patience. Most founders and boards do not.

Do you agree? Has marketing become too addicted to quick wins?

If you’d like my help with your brand?
Send me an email, and let’s get to work.